5 Pumpkin Varieties Perfect for Pumpkin Purée and Holiday Baking

The jack-o’-lantern on your porch is the worst baking pumpkin on the market — watery, stringy, and bland. These five varieties are what pie makers actually roast, ranked by what each does best, so your purée starts sweeter before sugar ever enters the bowl.

The 5 Varieties

1. Sugar Pie (aka New England Pie): the benchmark — small, dense, sweet flesh that roasts into classic pie purée. If the farm stand has one pumpkin, it’s this.
2. Long Island Cheese: pale, wheel-shaped, and named for its cheese-box looks; custard-silky flesh that many bakers swear beats Sugar Pie for pies.
3. Jarrahdale: the blue-gray stunner from Australia — dry, sweet, string-free flesh that’s spectacular in cheesecakes and quick breads.
4. Red Kuri: chestnut-flavored and vivid orange; skin softens enough to blend, making it the low-effort choice for soups and purée alike.
5. Butternut (yes, technically a squash): the canned-‘pumpkin’ industry’s open secret — reliable, sweet, and available all winter when true pie pumpkins vanish.

Pro tip: Whatever you roast, drain the purée in a sieve for 30 minutes — water content is the variable that breaks pie recipes.

Gluten-Free Notes

If you are cooking for someone with celiac disease, cross-contact matters as much as ingredients — clean surfaces, dedicated utensils, and certified or labeled gluten-free packaged goods are the safe path.

This post contains an Amazon affiliate link. As an Amazon Associate, glutenfreefarina.com/ may earn from qualifying purchases.

Browse more in Baking Basics & Pantry, or explore our gluten-free breakfast recipe database and hot cereal guide.